Fall 2024
Undergraduate Lectures
PHIL UN1001 Introduction to Philosophy
Survey of some of the central problems, key figures, and great works in both traditional and contemporary philosophy. Topics and texts will vary with instructor and semester.
Section 001
F. Russell
MW 11:40am-12:55pm; 304 Barnard Hall
Section 002
C. Prodoehl
TR 2:40pm-3:55pm; 207 Milbank Hall (Barnard)
Section 003
C. Bowman
MW 4:10pm-5:25pm; 203 Diana Center
PHIL UN2101 History of Philosophy I
T. Pincin
TR 4:10pm-5:25pm; 141 Uris Hall
Corequisites: PHIL V2111 Required Discussion Section (0 points). Exposition and analysis of the positions of the major philosophers from the pre-Socratics through Augustine.
PHIL UN2110 Philosophy & Feminism
C. Mercer
TR 2:40pm-3:55pm; 833 Seeley W. Mudd Building
Is there an essential difference between women and men? How do questions about race conflict or overlap with those about gender? Is there a normal way of being queer? Introduction to philosophy and feminism through a critical discussion of these and other questions using historical and contemporary texts, art, and public lectures. Focus includes essentialism, difference, identity, knowledge, objectivity, and queerness.
PHIL UN2301 History of Philosophy III: Kant-Nietzsche
F. Neuhouser
TR 8:40am-9:55am; 405 Milbank Hall (Barnard)
Prerequisites: None. Exposition and analysis of major texts and figures in European philosophy since Kant. Authors include Kant, Hegel, Schopenhauer, Kierkegaard, and Nietzsche. Required discussion section (PHIL UN2311). Attendance in the first week of classes is mandatory.
PHIL UN2655 Cognitive Science and Philosophy
B. Fleig-Goldstein
TR 11:40am-12:55pm; 313 Fayerweather
This course will survey a number of topics at the intersection of cognitive science and philosophy. Potential topics include free will, consciousness, embodied cognition, artificial intelligence, neural networks, and the language of thought.
PHIL UN2685 Introduction to Philosophy of Language
K. Lewis
MW 2:40pm-3:55pm; 418 Barnard Hall
This course gives students an introduction to various topics in the Philosophy of Language. Required discussion section (PHIL UN2686).
PHIL UN3352 20th Century European Philosophy
T. Carman
MW 10:10am-11:25am; 302 Barnard Hall
Prerequisites: one prior philosophy course. Reading and discussion of selected texts by central figures in phenomenology, existentialism, hermeneutics, critical theory, and recent Continental philosophy. Authors may include Heidegger, Sartre, Merleau-Ponty, Gadamer, Horkheimer, Adorno, Foucault, Bourdieu.
PHIL UN3353 European Social Philosophy
A. Honneth
TR 10:10am-11:25am; 326 Uris Hall
Prerequisites: one philosophy course. A survey of Eurpoean social philosophy from the 18th to the 20th century, with special attention to theories of capitalism and the normative concepts (freedom, alienation, human flourishing) that inform them. Also: the relationship between civil society and the state. Topic: The Critical Theory of the Frankfurt School
PHIL UN3411 Symbolic Logic
T. Lando
MW 10:10am-11:25am; 417 International Affairs Building
Corequisites: PHILV3413 Required Discussion Section (0 points). Advanced introduction to classical sentential and predicate logic. No previous acquaintance with logic is required; nonetheless a willingness to master technicalities and to work at a certain level of abstraction is desirable.
PHIL UN3601 Metaphysics
A. Varzi
MW 1:10pm-2:25pm; 702 Hamilton Hall
Corequisites: PHIL V3611 Required Discussion Section (0 points). Systematic treatment of some major topics in metaphysics (e.g. modality, causation, identity through time, particulars and universals). Readings from contemporary authors.
PHIL UN3701 Ethics
M. Moody-Adams
MW 1:10pm-2:25pm; 517 Hamilton Hall
Prerequisites: one course in philosophy. Corequisites: PHIL V3711 Required Discussion Section (0 points). This course is mainly an introduction to three influential approaches to normative ethics: utilitarianism, deontological views, and virtue ethics. We also consider the ethics of care, and selected topics in meta-ethics.
PHIL UN3751 Political Philosophy
F. Neuhouser
TR 1:10pm-2:25pm; 405 Milbank Hall (Barnard)
Six major concepts of political philosophy including authority, rights, equality, justice, liberty and democracy are examined in three different ways. First the conceptual issues are analyzed through contemporary essays on these topics by authors like Peters, Hart, Williams, Berlin, Rawls and Schumpeter. Second the classical sources on these topics are discussed through readings from Hobbes, Locke, Hume, Marx, Plato, Mill and Rousseau. Third some attention is paid to relevant contexts of application of these concepts in political society, including such political movements as anarchism, international human rights, conservative, liberal, and Marxist economic policies as well as competing models of democracy.
Majors Seminar
Required of senior majors, but also open to junior majors, and junior and senior concentrators who have taken at least four philosophy courses. This exploration will typically involve writing a substantial research paper. Capped at 20 students with preference to philosophy majors.
To register for a Majors Seminar, please complete this form.
PHIL UN3912 Section 001
Angels, Demons, & Artificial Intelligence
D. Jagannathan
W 10:10am-12:00pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
PHIL UN3912 Section 002
Anger, Forgiveness, and Reconciliation in Ethics and Politics
M. Moody-Adams
T 2:10pm-4:00pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
The course explores philosophical reflection on the role of anger, forgiveness, and reconciliation in public and private life. Readings will be drawn from historical as well as contemporary sources, and from non-Western as well as Western traditions.
PHIL UN3912 Section 003
Philosophy of Language
M. Fusco
T 6:10pm-8:00pm; 201A Philosophy Hall
******************************************
PHIL BC4050
F. Russell
W 4:10pm-6:00pm; 307 Milbank Hall (Barnard)
Intensive study of a philosophical issue or topic, or of a philosopher, group of philosophers, or philosophical school or movement. Open only to Barnard senior philosophy majors.
4000-Level Seminars
4000-level courses are open to advanced undergraduate students and graduate students.
PHIL GU4353 Later Heidegger
T. Carman
W 2:10pm-4:00pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
PHIL GU4424 Modal Logic
T. Lando
MW 1:10pm-2:25pm; 516 Hamilton Hall
PHIL GU4651 Probability & Decision Theory
J. Collins
R 12:10pm-2:00pm; 602 Northwest Corner Building
Examines interpretations and applications of the calculus of probability including applications as a measure of degree of belief, degree of confirmation, relative frequency, a theoretical property of systems, and other notions of objective probability or chance. Attention to epistimological questions such as Hume's problem of induction, Goodman's problem of projectibility, and the paradox of confirmation.
PHIL GU4602 Philosophical Texts in Greek
W. Mann
W 6:10pm-8:00pm; 317 Hamilton Hall
Text: Aristotle's Metaphysics. Careful reading and translation of a major philosophical text in ancient Greek to be chosen by the course participants in consultation with the instructor. Special attention is to be paid to the linguistic and conceptual problems of translating ancient Greek philosophical texts. Prerequisite: equivalent of at least two years of study of ancient Greek at university level.
Graduate Lectures
PHIL GR5415 Symbolic Logic
T. Lando
MW 10:10am-11:25am; 417 International Affairs Building
Advanced introduction to classical sentential and predicate logic. No previous acquaintance with logic is required; nonetheless a willingness to master technicalities and to work at a certain level of abstraction is desirable. Note: Due to significant overlap, students may receive credit for only one of the following three courses: PHIL UN3411, UN3415, GR5415.
Graduate Seminars
PHIL GR6050 Methods and Problems
M. Fusco
M 2:10pm-4:00pm; 302 Fayerweather
Theoretical Philosophy. This class covers classic readings in contemporary philosophy, selections from historical authors that bear on today’s debates, and influential recent contributions in a range of subfields such as metaphysics, philosophy of mind, epistemology, logic, philosophy of language, philosophy of science, philosophy of mathematics, and philosophy of cognitive science. This course is restricted to MA students in Philosophy only.
PHIL GR6880 1st Year Proseminar in Philosophy
J. Clarke-Doane
M 6:10pm-8:00pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
PHIL GR9110 Metaethics
A. Bilgrami
T 6:10pm-8:00pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
Topic: Intentionality, normativity, rule-following, and self-knowledge. What is realism and how does it relate to objectivity? In this course, we will consider a range of answers, with special attention to problems of value. We will begin by clarifying the nature of realism about a subject matter and arguments that might support it. We will then look at limitations of realism per se, and the need to supplement it with a distinct notion of objectivity. Next, we will consider arguments that “realist objectivism”, while attractive, is an untenable package. This will lead us to discuss anti-objectivist forms of realism and their deflationary methodological ramifications. Finally, we will look at the prospects for objectivity without realism, particularly in the evaluative case. We will conclude by sketching a neo-pragmatist metaphilosophical outlook.
PHIL GR9180 Topics in Moral Philosophy
Prerequisites: the instructor's permission. At least one foundational course in moral philosophy is recommended as background for this course. In this seminar we will take up several questions about moral understanding and insight. Questions we will consider include: Can trusting moral testimony ever be rational or right? Are the reasons to be cautions about relying on moral testimony moral reasons or epistemic reasons (or both)? What assumptions about moral knowledge do critics and defenders of moral testimony make? How does moral knowledge differ, if it does, from moral understanding? Is there such a thing as moral expertise? Is there any reason to think that moral expertise is more problematic than other kinds of expertise? Can emotions inform us about value? Under what conditions, if any, can emotions contribute to our understanding of value? Under what conditions are emotions impediments to moral knowledge or understanding? Can fictions help us gain moral insight? Can pictures ever be legitimate tools of moral persuasion?
Section 001
K. Vogt
M 2:10pm-4:00pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
Approaches to Applied Ethics
Section 002
A. Honneth
W 4:10pm-6:00pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
Nietzsche - The Genealogy of Morals
PHIL GR9521 Topics in Theory of Knowledge
J. Collins
R 6:10pm-8:00pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
Causal Decision Theory
PHIL GR9642 Practical Reason
J. Clarke-Doane
W 6:10pm-8:00pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
PHIL GR9670 Topics in Early Modern Philosophy
C. Mercer
W 2:10pm-4:00pm; 507 Lewisohn Hall
The Woman Question
PHIL GR9985 Proposal Preparation Seminar
K. Vogt
M 10:10am-12:00pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
PHIL GR9991 Job Placement Seminar
L. Goehr
M 6:10pm-8:00pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
Summer 2024
Undergraduate Lectures
PHIL S3350 Existentialism
J. Hamilton
Session B July 1-August 9, 2024
TR 1:00pm-4:10pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
A survey of major themes of Existentialist philosophy in Europe from the mid 19th century to the mid 20th century, this class will focus on Kierkegaard, Heidegger, and Sartre and their influences on philosophical conceptions of the human being and the form of its freedom, and the consequences of anxiety, nihilism, and despair in the face of death.
PHIL S3411 Introduction to Symbolic Logic
S. Burns
Session A May 20-June 28, 2024
MW 9:00am-12:10pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
Advanced introduction to classical sentential and predicate logic. No previous acquaintance with logic is required; nonetheless a willingness to master technicalities and to work at a certain level of abstraction is desirable.
PHIL S3551 Philosophy of Science
L. Clark
Session B July 1-August 9, 2024
TR 9:00am-12:10pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
Philosophical problems within science and about the nature of scientific knowledge in the 17th-20th centuries. Sample problems: causation and scientific explanation; induction and real kinds; verification and falsification; models, analogies and simulations; the historical origins of the modern sciences; scientific revolutions; reductionism and supervenience; differences between physics, biology and the social sciences; the nature of life; cultural evolution; human nature; philosophical issues in cosmology.
PHIL S3601 Metaphysics
N. Betz-Richman
Session B July 1-August 9, 2024
MW 1:00pm-4:10pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
This course will survey topics in contemporary metaphysics. We will focus on material objects, time, modality, causation, properties, and natural kinds. We will begin by considering what objects there are in general (ontology) and what to say about certain puzzling entities (such as holes). Then we will turn to debates about material objects and puzzles about composite objects and the notion of parthood. Next is the issue of how material objects persist over time and survive change in their parts. We shall consider two important views on persistence. We then turn to two issues related to persistence: personal identity over time, and puzzles about time travel. This will lead us into the next part of the course on modality and causation, which concerns the notions of possibility, necessity, laws of nature, and causation. We will consider different views about 'possible worlds'. We will then consider the nature of laws and causation and then turn to the problem of free will. We will look at debates in the metaphysics of properties between realists and nominalists about properties. Then we'll consider causal powers, dispositions, and natural kinds. The section will conclude with problems about the metaphysics of socially constructed kinds such as race or gender.
PHIL S3701 Ethics
Q. Cao
Session A May 20-June 28, 2024
TR 9:00am-12:10pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
Sessions held on 6/25 and 6/27 have been cancelled. Make up sessions will be held on 5/31 and 6/14. Please plan accordingly.
Prerequisites: One philosophy course This course is mainly an introduction to three influential approaches to normative ethics: utilitarianism, deontological views, and virtue ethics. We also consider the ethics of care, and selected topics in meta-ethics.
Spring 2024
Undergraduate Lectures
PHIL UN1001 Introduction to Philosophy
F. Russell
Section 001: TR 2:40pm-3:55pm; 207 Milbank Hall (at Barnard College)
Section 002: MW 1:10ppm-2:25pm; 307 Milbank Hall (at Barnard College)
Survey of some of the central problems, key figures, and great works in both traditional and contemporary philosophy. Topics and texts will vary with instructor and semester.
PHIL UN1010 Methods & Problems of Philosophical Thought
M. Fusco
TR 1:10pm-2:25pm; 141 Uris Hall
A critical introduction to philosophical problems, ideas and methods.
PHIL UN1401 Introduction to Logic
C. Prodoehl
TR 11:40am-12:55pm; 405 Milbank Hall (at Barnard College)
Explicit criteria for recognizing valid and fallacious arguments, together with various methods for schematizing discourse for the purpose of logical analysis. Illustrative material taken from science and everyday life.
PHIL UN2301 History of Philosophy III: Kant-Nietzsche (at Barnard College)
T. Carman
MW 8:40am-9:55am; 504 Diana Center
Prerequisites: None. Exposition and analysis of major texts and figures in European philosophy since Kant. Authors include Kant, Hegel, Schopenhauer, Kierkegaard, and Nietzsche. Required discussion section (PHIL UN2311). Attendance in the first week of classes is mandatory.
PHIL UN2655 Cognitive Science and Philosophy
J. Vazard
TR 2:40pm-3:55pm; 331 Uris Hall
This course will survey a number of topics at the intersection of cognitive science and philosophy. Potential topics include free will, consciousness, embodied cognition, artificial intelligence, neural networks, and the language of thought.
PHIL UN3251 Kant
F. Neuhouser
MW 11:40am-12:55pm; 405 Milbank Hall (at Barnard College)
Explores the connections between theoretical and practical reason in Kant's thinking with special attention to the Critique of Pure Reason and the project of transcendental philosophy.
PHIL UN3351 Phenomenology & Existentialism (at Barnard College)
T. Carman
MW 10:10am-11:25am; LL104 Diana Center
DESCRIPTION TBA
PHIL UN3411 Symbolic Logic
J. Clarke-Doane
TR 7:40pm-8:55pm; 309 Havemeyer Hall
Corequisites: PHILUN3413 Required Discussion Section (0 points). Advanced introduction to classical sentential and predicate logic. No previous acquaintance with logic is required; nonetheless a willingness to master technicalities and to work at a certain level of abstraction is desirable.
PHIL UN3576 Physics and Philosophy
D. Albert
MW 4:10pm-5:25pm; 330 Uris Hall
Philosophical problems at the foundations of quantum theory, especially those having to do with the uncertainty of relations and nature of quantum mechanical indeterminacy. Exploration of a variety of interpretation and hidden variable theory.
PHIL UN3701 Ethics
M. Moody-Adams
MW 1:10pm-2:25pm; 142 Uris Hall
Prerequisites: one course in philosophy. Corequisites: PHIL UN3711 Required Discussion Section (0 points). This course is mainly an introduction to three influential approaches to normative ethics: utilitarianism, deontological views, and virtue ethics. We also consider the ethics of care, and selected topics in meta-ethics.
PHIL UN3751 Political Philosophy
A. Honneth
TR 2:40pm-3:55pm; 303 Uris Hall
Six major concepts of political philosophy including authority, rights, equality, justice, liberty and democracy are examined in three different ways. First the conceptual issues are analyzed through contemporary essays on these topics by authors like Peters, Hart, Williams, Berlin, Rawls and Schumpeter. Second the classical sources on these topics are discussed through readings from Hobbes, Locke, Hume, Marx, Plato, Mill and Rousseau. Third some attention is paid to relevant contexts of application of these concepts in political society, including such political movements as anarchism, international human rights, conservative, liberal, and Marxist economic policies as well as competing models of democracy.
PHIL UN3769 Living, Dying, and the Meaning of Life
K. Vogt, L. Dugdale, I. Rottenberg
TR 11:40am-12:55pm; Earl Hall Auditorium
Bringing together scholars from the fields of Philosophy, Medicine, Ethics, and Religion, this course exposes students to modes of inquiry that can help to answer central questions that are often elusive and/or unconsidered: What constitutes a good human life? What do I need to be truly happy? How does the fact that I will one day die impact how I should live today? This interdisciplinary course provides a rare opportunity to consider how a wide variety of thinkers and writers have approached these questions, while also engaging with them in a personal way within our contemporary context. Lectures will be combined with group discussion and a weekend retreat, creating possibilities for interpersonal engagement and deep learning.
PHIL UN3960 Epistemology
J. Collins
TR 1:10pm-2:25pm; 503 Hamilton Hall
Corequisites: PHIL W3963 Required Discussion Section (0 points). What can we know? What is knowledge? What are the different kinds of knowledge? We will read classic and contemporary texts for insight into these questions.
PHIL UN3996 Supervised Senior Research
Multiple sections
For undergraduate seniors whose thesis proposals are approved. Please register for the appropriate section with your advisor. Contact Prof. David Albert, Director of Undergraduate Studies, and Haley Donovan, Academic Programs Coordinator, for more information.
Undergraduate Lectures
PHIL GU4950 Economics & Philosophy (*Restricted to Economics-Philosophy Majors*)
M. Fusco
W 2:10pm-4:00pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
Prerequisites: ECON UN3211, ECON UN3213, ECON UN3412. Students will be contacted by the Economics department for pre-enrollment. Explores topics in the philosophy of economics such as welfare, social choice, and the history of political economy. Sometimes the emphasis is primarily historical and sometimes on the analysis of contemporary economic concepts and theories.
Majors Seminar
Required of senior majors, but also open to junior majors, and junior and senior concentrators who have taken at least four philosophy courses. This exploration will typically involve writing a substantial research paper. Capped at 20 students with preference to philosophy majors.
To register for a Majors Seminar, please complete this form.
PHIL UN3912 Section 001 (At Barnard)
Creativity
C. Prodoehl
W 4:10pm-6:00pm; 501 Diana Center
PHIL UN3912 Section 002
Scientific Theory
J. McDonald
T 4:10pm-6:00pm; 401 Hamilton Hall
This seminar will explore how scientists inquire about the world, ask what a scientific theory is up to, and examine how theories relate to reality.
Bridge Seminars
Music GU4325 Topics in Music Cognition
M. Kozak & C. Peacocke
W 4:10pm-6:00pm; 622 Dodge Hall
This advanced seminar builds on the Introduction to Music Cognition (MUSIC UN2320) with an in-depth inquiry into selected key topics in the field of Music Cognition. Specific topics vary each year, depending on interest and availability of instructors, and include human development; evolution; communication and music’s relation to language; embodied knowledge; first-person awareness; metaphor; ineffability; neuroscience; mental representations; memory and anticipation; cross-cultural studies; emotions; musical aesthetics; artificial intelligence; agency; creativity; and music’s relation to other art forms. Each semester the course delves into recent research on 3–4 of these topics, focusing in particular on how this research can be applied to questions of musical knowledge. Advanced readings are drawn from fields as diverse as music theory, psychology, biology, anthropology, philosophy, and neuroscience. They include general works in cognitive science, theoretical work focused on specific musical issues, and reports of empirical research.
PHIL GU4660 Philosophy of Mind
J. Morrison
M 2:10pm-4:00pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
Graduate Seminars
SOCI GR5001 Freedom: Inequality, Populism, and Democracy
A. Bilgrami & J. Cole
W 10:10am-12:00pm; 546 Greene Hall
The concept of freedom is analytically complex and has
a long and varied intellectual history. This course will focus on the
concept as it emerged in the modern period (roughly since the seventeenth
century in Europe) and focus in particular on three aspects of freedom.
Though the primary interest of the seminar will be on political and
academic freedom, it will be useful to begin with a very brief discussion
of the most abstract dimension of freedom by asking what notion of freedom
might individual human subjects be said to possess given the determinism
that seems to be everywhere indicated by the comprehensive explanatory
power of modern science.
NOTE: This is a graduate seminar. If undergraduate seniors wish to enroll they
should seek permission from the professors. The fourteen weeks of the
course will consist of a combination of 1) lectures by the instructors
followed by discussions, 2) discussions with guest visitors who are
distinguished scholars in the field and whose work will be pre-circulated
to the seminar, and 3) presentations by students on the readings on the
syllabus.
Requirements: Strictly regular attendance, prior reading of weekly texts,
and a term paper at the end of term of roughly 20-25 pages.
PHIL GR6100 MA Research Seminar
W. Mann
M 10:10am-12:00pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
The MA Research Seminar supports the research projects of MA students in Philosophy. Participants practice key methods in philosophy and deepen their knowledge of classic and contemporary contributions to the field. The seminar is suitable for everyone who is aiming to write a research paper. Seminar participants receive detailed input throughout the semester. Students can take the class at any stage during their studies for the MA. The class is graded Pass/ Fail.
PHIL GR6880 1st Year Proseminar (Required of all first-year Ph.D. candidates)
J. Clarke-Doane
W 6:10pm-8:00pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
Required of all first-year Ph.D. candidates.
PHIL GR9121 Topics in Ancient Philosophy
K. Vogt
T 2:10pm-4:00pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
Topic: Aristotle
PHIL GR9659 Naturalism
N. Nemati
R 10:10am-12:00pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
It is highly recommended that students have completed a philosophy of mind course (PHILGR9658). The successes of the physical sciences in the 19th and 20th century solidified naturalism as the dominant ideology of analytic philosophy. While lacking any precise definition, naturalism broadly takes science to be epistemically and ontologically privileged over other forms of inquiry, guiding and constraining philosophy itself. Today, questions not only concerning ‘what the world is like’ but also philosophical queries into theory of knowledge and meaning, metaphysics, ethics, and philosophy of mind defer to the sciences and the scientific method. But what makes science an epistemically and ontologically privileged enterprise? What relation does science maintain to philosophy? What arguments are there for different kinds of naturalism?
In this course, we will ask these questions, both with a focus on efforts to naturalize the mind and an eye toward the historical context in which these efforts developed. We will explore the relationship between naturalizing psychological properties and physicalism, the relationship between naturalism and representationalism, phenomenological critiques of naturalism, and proposed alternatives to naturalism.
PHIL GR9750 Topics in Political Philosophy
M. Moody-Adams
M 4:10pm-6:00pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
Topic: Democratic Citizenship. This graduate seminar in political philosophy explores the problems and possibilities of democratic citizenship. We consider primarily recent accounts of democratic citizenship, with some attention to important historical antecedents of these accounts. Instructor approval is required for this course.
PHIL GR9755 Problems of Social Philosophy
A. Honneth and F. Neuhouser
W 4:10pm-6:00pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
Topic: Sartre's critique of dialectic reason. Priority will be given to Columbia GSAS MA and PhD students. All other students must obtain permission from the instructors to register.
PHIL GR9990 Thesis Preparation Seminar
C. Peacocke
R 2:10pm-4:00pm; 716 Philosophy Hall
The purposes of the Seminar are (a) to aid graduates in developing and refining material for their dissertation; (b) to give graduates experience in presenting material to a philosophical audience in an informed and supportive environment; (c) to give graduates experience in critically discussing presented material, and thereby to see how their own presentations and work can be developed to withstand critical examination. The Seminar is restricted to Columbia graduate students in their third or later years, and all such students are strongly encouraged to attend. No faculty (other than the organizer) will be present. Those attending the seminar will be expected to make one or more presentations of work in progress. The material for a presentation may range from a near-final draft of a chapter, to an early critical overview of an area with an outline plan for an approach to some chosen problem. We will attempt as far as possible to organize the presentations in such a way that they are grouped by subject-matter, and provide a rational path through the territory we cover.
Fall 2023
Undergraduate Lectures
PHIL UN1001 Introduction to Philosophy (at Barnard College)
Survey of some of the central problems, key figures, and great works in both traditional and contemporary philosophy. Topics and texts will vary with instructor and semester.
Section 001
C. Prodoehl
TR 2:40pm-3:55pm; 324 Milbank
Section 002
C. Van Dyke
MW 10:10am-11:25am; 307 Milbank
Section 003
T. Carman
MW 8:40am-9:55am; 202 Milbank
PHIL UN1010 Methods & Problems of Philosophical Thought
J. McDonald
TR 1:10 PM-2:25 PM; Uris 331
A critical introduction to philosophical problems, ideas and methods.
PHIL UN2101 History of Philosophy I
D. Jagnnathan
TR 2:40pm-3:55pm; Uris 142
Corequisites: PHIL UN2111. Required Discussion Section (0 points). An exposition and analysis of the positions of the major philosophers from the pre-Socratics through Augustine.
PHIL UN3353 European Social Philosophy
A. Honneth
TR 10:10am-11:25am; Uris 141
Prerequisites: one philosophy course. A survey of European social philosophy from the 18th to the 20th century, with special attention to theories of capitalism and the normative concepts (freedom, alienation, human flourishing) that inform them. Also: the relationship between civil society and the state.
PHIL UN3411 Symbolic Logic
T. Lando
MW 10:10am-11:25am; Uris 301
Corequisites: PHILUN3413. Required Discussion Section (0 points). Advanced introduction to classical sentential and predicate logic. No previous acquaintance with logic is required; nonetheless a willingness to master technicalities and to work at a certain level of abstraction is desirable.
PHIL UN3551 Philosophy of Science
D. Albert
MW 6:10pm-7:25pm; Philosophy 716
Philosophical problems within science and about the nature of scientific knowledge in the 17th-20th centuries. Sample problems: causation and scientific explanation; induction and real kinds; verification and falsification; models, analogies and simulations; the historical origins of the modern sciences; scientific revolutions; reductionism and supervenience; differences between physics, biology and the social sciences; the nature of life; cultural evolution; human nature; philosophical issues in cosmology.
PHIL UN3601 Metaphysics
J. Clarke Doane
TR 6:10pm-7:25pm; Fayerweather 313
Corequisites: PHIL UN3611. Required Discussion Section (0 points). Systematic treatment of some major topics in metaphysics (e.g. modality, causation, identity through time, particulars and universals). Readings from contemporary authors.
PHIL UN3651 Philosophy of Mind
M. Fusco
TR 11:40am-12:55pm; Hamilton 702
PHIL UN3716 Advanced Topics in Ethics
C. Rovane
MW 2:40pm-3:55pm; Kraft 5AB
Undergraduate Seminars
PHIL UN3871 If I Were You: Identity, Essence, Limits
M. Botti
W 12:10pm-2:00pm; Lerner - Satow Room
This course will be devoted to the topic of being other than oneself and the metaphysical debate surrounding questions like: What does the possibility of being different from who we are amount to? What does it mean to be someone else? How different from ourselves can we be? Students will be offered analytical and philosophical tools that will help them to rigorously formulate those and related questions, and to think through the nature of modal variation and its boundaries. In the final weeks of the semester, we will explore the application of those theoretical tools to relevant themes in metaphysics of gender. Throughout the seminar, students will be encouraged to think of the implications of our discussion for related debates in philosophy, especially in the epistemology of the modal and counterfactual claims at issue. This course will be most suitable for students who have some background in analytical metaphysics, e.g. Philosophy 3601, “Metaphysics."
Majors Seminar
Required of senior majors, but also open to junior majors, and junior and senior concentrators who have taken at least four philosophy courses. This exploration will typically involve writing a substantial research paper. Capped at 20 students with preference to philosophy majors.
PHIL UN3912 Section 001
Dissent, Protest, Disobedience
M. Moody-Adams
M 4:10pm-6:00pm; Philosophy 716
PHIL UN3912 Section 002
Classical Indian Philosophy
A. Aitken
W 4:10pm-6:00pm; Philosophy 716
Bridge Lectures
PHIL GU4055 Aesthetics: Modern Survey
L. Goehr
M 6:10pm-8:00pm; Northwest Corner 602
PHIL GU4431 Introduction to Set Theory
T. Lando
MW 10:10am-11:25am; Hamilton 303
PHIL GU4561 Probability and Decision Theory
J. Collins
R 10:10am-12:00pm; Philosophy 716
Examines interpretations and applications of the calculus of probability including applications as a measure of degree of belief, degree of confirmation, relative frequency, a theoretical property of systems, and other notions of objective probability or chance. Attention to epistemological questions such as Hume's problem of induction, Goodman's problem of projectability, and the paradox of confirmation.
Bridge Seminars
PHIL GU4740 Islamic Philosophy
S. B. Diagne
T 4:10pm-6:00pm; Mathematics 417
Graduate Lectures
PHIL GU5415 Symbolic Logic
T. Lando
MW 10:10am-11:25am; Uris 301
Advanced introduction to classical sentential and predicate logic. No previous acquaintance with logic is required; nonetheless a willingness to master technicalities and to work at a certain level of abstraction is desirable. Note: Due to significant overlap, students may receive credit for only one of the following three courses: PHIL UN3411, UN3415, GR5415.
Graduate Seminars
PHIL GR6880 Proseminar (*Required of all first-year Ph.D. in Philosophy candidates.)
J. Clarke Doane
W 6:10pm-8:00pm; Hamilton 406
Each faculty member addresses the proseminar in order to acquaint students with the interests and areas of expertise on the faculty. Through discussion and the dissemination of readings the student learns about possible areas of doctoral research.
PHIL GR9525 Heidegger's Being and Time
T. Carman
W 2:10-4pm; Philosophy 716
PHIL GR9525 Topics in the Philosophy of Language
M. Fusco
F 12:10pm-2:00pm; Philosophy 716
PHIL GR9576 Philosophy of Space and Time
D. Albert
M 12:10pm-2:00pm; Philosophy 716
PHIL GR9658 Advanced Topics in the Philosophy of Mind
C. Peacocke
R 2:10pm-4:00pm; Philosophy 716
The first third of this Seminar will introduce a framework and theory for addressing the nature of intentional content, and apply it to such classical issues as the structure of justification, the a priori, and logical inference. The remainder of the Seminar will apply the theory to develop an account of intentional content in the perception of music. I will use the resulting account to explain the significance and interest of music, musical communication, the mental representation of music, and the relation of music to other art forms, especially poetry.
PHIL GR9982 Aesthetics and the Philosophy of Art II
A. Honneth
T 6:10pm-8:00pm; Philosophy 716